Laying workers raise nothing but drones

Laying workers develop when a hive becomes queenless or when an existing queen begins to fail. As the queen’s pheromone levels decrease, the ovaries of some of the workers may begin to develop. If other workers begin to feed these bees royal jelly, they begin to lay eggs. The whole process happens two to three weeks after the loss of the queen.

Since workers cannot mate, the eggs of laying workers produce drones. If you recall, when the queen lays a fertilized egg, the offspring is female and has two sets of 16 chromosomes—or 32 total. If the queen lays an unfertilized egg, the offspring is male and has one set of  chromosomes—or 16 total.

The worker-laid eggs will all have just the one set of chromosomes. And since a colony cannot survive with nothing but drones, it will soon die. In addition, it is almost impossible to re-queen a hive with laying workers. This is because the laying workers give off a queen-like pheromone that prevents a real queen from being accepted into the colony.

So how do you know if you have laying workers? There are four major indicators:

  • A scattered brood pattern (this occurs because worker eggs are often eaten by other workers)
  • Cells with multiple eggs (this occurs because there may be multiple workers laying eggs at the same time)
  • Worker-sized brood cells that have the conical cappings characteristic of drones (this is because the workers don’t seem to “know” they are laying all drone eggs)
  • Eggs adhering to the side of cells rather than being centered in the bottom of the cells (this occurs because the worker abdomen is too short to reach all the way down to the bottom of the cell)

So what do you do with a hive of laying workers that you can’t re-queen? One answer is to set up a new hive in the old position with a new caged queen and some brood frames taken from another hive. Then take the laying-worker hive to the edge of your apiary and shake the bees from the frames. Most of the bees will fly back and enter the new hive. The laying workers don’t usually make it back because they’ve become too large and heavy to fly (think pregnant.)

Keep your queen caged for a few days and check for laying workers before you release her.

If you don’t have a new queen on hand, you can combine the laying-worker colony with a queenright colony. You might want to use a double-screen board for a couple days until the real queen’s pheromones overpower the worker pheromones.

Rusty

Scattered drone brood typical of laying workers. Photo by the author.
Scattered drone brood typical of laying workers. Photo by the author.

Comments

Robert
Reply

I have this issue. The odd thing is, there is a queen in the colony. I introduced it last week. Can you tell me if I did the right thing?
I opened the hive and caught the new queen and placed her in a box. I then took the hive apart and carried it 50 yards or so from the original location. I then removed all the bees by shaking and blowing from all the frames. By the time I got everything back, there were tons of bees looking for the hive. I then reassembled the hive and let everyone settle down a bit and released the queen.
I also pulled a frame of brood from the other hive and placed it in this hive. Can you think of anything else I can do to help this hive?
Thanks

Rusty
Reply

Robert,

No, I know of nothing else. Those are all the steps I know for overcoming laying workers. It should work, especially if they accepted the new queen. Are you sure you had laying workers?

Robert
Reply

Well, I can say for sure but there was no brood last week and this week there was shotgun drone cells. They were pretty sparse maybe 30 or 40 of them.
When do you recommend I check them again?
Thanks

Rusty
Reply

Robert,

A week after introducing the mated queen.

Leave a comment

name*

email* (not published)

website