Queenless or clueless?

It happens. You open your hive and you can’t find your queen. Worse, you see no young brood—no larvae, no eggs. Several things are possible:

  • Your queen is dead.
  • Your queen is failing and is being superseded.
  • Your queen has swarmed.
  • You have a queen that hasn’t started laying.
  • You have a virgin queen.

At this point, you wonder what to do. You could buy a queen, but maybe you have a virgin queen or a newly mated queen and you just didn’t see her. Or maybe you can’t find her because she’s out on a mating flight this very minute. You hate the idea of adding a new queen, only to have them duke it out later. So what do you do?

The very best and least risky thing you can do is add a frame or two of mixed brood from another hive. By mixed brood, I mean brood in various stages of development from eggs to larvae to capped pupae. Here’s why:

  • A good supply of eggs and recently hatched larvae means the colony can raise a queen on their own if they need one. And if they don’t need one, no harm is done.
  • Brood, especially larvae, give off pheromones that reduce the likelihood of laying workers even if no queen is present.
  • If a queen needs to be raised, the capped brood and older larvae will supply the colony with new workers in the meantime.

As you can see, the colony—whether queenless or not—has everything to gain and nothing to lose with an infusion of brood. But what about the hive you stole from? Are you running a risk of weakening that colony?

A little judgment is useful when stealing brood. If you steal it from a populous and thriving hive, it won’t make any difference as long as you don’t accidentally take the queen. Shake all the bees from the frames you take to make sure you don’t have her.

If the hive you steal from is of only moderate strength, take frames that contain mostly eggs. The reason is that the donor colony hasn’t spent a lot of time, energy, or resources on a frame of eggs and it won’t take long for the colony to replace it. Larvae and capped brood, on the other hand, have taken a great deal of effort. So, if you are at all concerned about the strength of the donor colony, stick to stealing eggs—it’s like taking pennies instead of dollars.

The beauty of this system is that you don’t have to know whether you have a queen or not, or whether she’s a virgin or not. If they need a queen they can raise one. And if they don’t, you’ve done no harm.

A final thought: whenever I write something like this I realize there are beekeepers with only one hive. I can’t think of anything trickier. If you have only one hive—or if you haven’t yet started beekeeping—consider getting a second colony. It doesn’t just double your options; it multiplies them many times over.

Rusty
HoneyBeeSuite

The queen can quickly replace lost eggs. Flickr photo by steveburt1947.
The queen can quickly replace lost eggs. Flickr photo by steveburt1947.

Comments

Nancy
Reply

Wow! This is exactly what we did last week with one of my friend’s hives that was packed with honey but had no brood. He re-queened because the hive had a mean attitude. Guess they liked their mean queen and didn’t like the nice new one.

But my question is, if I’m checking hives and see the queen, could I mark her? What’s the stuff you use, and how can I keep from doing her or the bees any harm? It would save so much anxiety. Thanks.
Nan

HERB
Reply

RUSTY! You seem to know when I experience a queen loss. Thanks for the Great advice!

Emily
Reply

The only time this doesn’t work is when you transfer the frame over, they produce a new queen and then it rains for three weeks solid. Your lovely new queen can’t get out to mate and becomes a drone layer. You bump her off and try again with another frame, but by this time your hive population has shrunk, you have few nurse bees and the weather’s still wet and cold, so they can’t keep the brood warm enough and the queen cells they produce never hatch out.

Eventually you end up combining your weak queenless hive with the stronger one. Happened to us in London this year; we’ve had the most unbelievably ridiculous weather, including the rainiest April since records began. Even now it’s June the rain and winds aren’t over. In hindsight we’d have been better off buying in a mated queen—but we didn’t know the summer was going to be this useless!

Tricia
Reply

Another reason for no eggs—at least here in the UK—is that you have just put in a treatment for varroa. When I had my first bees and treated as dealer recommended I was quite nonplussed by this. Established beekeepers will know but new ones reading may not. Of course the beauty of your advice (frame of eggs from elsewhere) is that it does no harm, but the new beekeeper may be the one who only has one hive. Great post as usual.

Rusty
Reply

Good point. I hadn’t thought of that possibility.

Charlie
Reply

Good article Rusty! I sent your link to our beginner beeks to absorb.

Rusty
Reply

Thanks so much, Charlie!

Nancy
Reply

So, can I mark my queen?

Leave a comment

name*

email* (not published)

website