Yes, she’s a worker, but what kind?
Don’t let the phrase “temporal caste” scare you away. Temporal means “related to time” and castes are social groups with physical differences designed for special jobs. All beekeepers already know about temporal castes in honey bees, but few know the name.
Queens and workers
Female honey bees are born into one of two physical castes: they are either workers or queens. These bees have some obvious physical differences that we can see. Queens are bigger than workers with long abdomens and legs that splay away from their bodies. Their wings are about the same size as worker wings, but they appear short compared to their abdomens. They also have a large bare spot on their thorax and lack corbiculae on their hind legs.
Queens also have differences we can’t easily see just by looking. They have well-developed reproductive systems and pheromone-secreting glands, for example. Mated queens have an overflowing spermatheca for storing sperm for years and their stinger is smooth and knife-like, suitable for reuse.
The caste honey bees are born into doesn’t change. Queens don’t shrivel into workers, and workers don’t grow into fully functioning queens.
Temporal castes are temporary
Temporal castes are based on temporary periods of highly specialized work. The work is so specialized, in fact, that it requires changes in the physiology or anatomy of the individual. This phenomenon is called temporal polyethism, a word derived from “many gods.” Worker bees go from one job assignment to another as they age. In times of colony stress, older bees can sometimes revert to a job they held as a youngster.
The key to defining a temporal caste is a physical change in an individual. For example, nurse bees and comb-building bees are both workers. Structurally, they look the same. But nurses have highly developed hypopharyngeal glands that allow them to feed the developing larvae. Comb-building bees have shrunken hypopharyngeal glands and lose the ability to provide brood food but produce large amounts of wax from glands in the abdomen.
We don’t fully understand how they change from one temporal caste to another. On the surface, a worker bee appears to go from one job to another in a more or less orderly fashion, with each temporal caste lasting about a week. But the roadmap is unclear—not all bees do all the jobs.
What causes change during colony stress?
Some researchers say that if a bee can go “willy nilly” from one job to another, there is no temporal caste system. Others point out that stimuli from within the colony cause the changes, not individual choice. And because the change requires physical re-tooling of the bee’s body, it meets the definition of temporal polyethism.
As in the previous example, workers with developed hypopharyngeal glands don’t have developed wax glands—time is necessary to make the change. Hence, the stages are temporal. Other temporal assignments, some with fewer physical changes, include cleaning, guarding, undertaking, scouting, and foraging.
Even laying workers can change back to regular workers if enough open worker-brood pheromone is present to suppress their ovaries. It is a temporary, although often terminal, situation.
Are winter bees their own caste?
To make things more complicated, the physiology of winter bees differs from spring and summer bees, but they don’t behave like a temporal caste. Winter bees are born as winter bees. They are not summer bees that change into winter bees. Pollen shortages in late autumn appear to stimulate the production of winter bees in the colony, a natural part of winter preparations.
Winter bees have obvious physical differences that allow them to store large amounts of brood food within their bodies. They also have unseen differences that extend their life expectancies from weeks into months. And even when their fat bodies become depleted, they do not become regular workers.
We know this because, unlike summer bees, winter bees do not have a division of labor in their ranks. Winter bees are generalists, doing what’s needed in the hive with no physical changes required. Instead of shape-shifting to do a different job, they simply do what’s needed. What one can do, they all can do.
Taken together, all these factors suggest winter bees are not a temporal caste, but perhaps a third female caste, giving us queens, workers, and winter bees.
Other insects with temporal castes
Insects with both physical castes and temporal castes include honey bees, stingless bees, and ants. Others have similar social structures that are less defined and obvious, such as termites, bumble bees, sweat bees, and social wasps.
Honey Bee Suite
While I enjoyed reading this, and it gave me a new way to think about division of labor in honey bee colonies, I can’t help being disappointed that you weren’t writing about bees who travel by TARDIS.
Well, I can’t please all of the people all of the time.
Ya know I love ya, right. Or at least I love your writing. : )
After losing your bees to the bears, did you ever get back into beekeeping?
In a very limited way, so far.
The more you know the more complicated it gets, isn’t it? Alternative; the more we know the more we realise how ignorant we are.
In the northeast some drones survive the winter. I wonder if they have any physical differences.
Regarding your opening “Female honey bees are born into one of two physical castes: they are either workers or queens.” I’ve told folks for some time that any fertile egg could become a queen.” “…born into…” must mean emerged as adult, yes/no?
People mentioned that the honey bee larva spins itself a cocoon. How do they know that?
Are there pictures or videos to prove this?
The cocoon is spun at the end of the larval cycle right before the larva becomes a pupa. The pupal stage is spent in the cocoon. The cocoon sticks to the wall of the wax cell and is difficult to see. After many generations of bees, the brood cells actually become smaller because of all the layers of cocoons that are left inside.
This whole discussion is fascinating to me. Honey bees border on the realm of magical in my book.
Hi Rusty, I am from west-central Alberta. I must tell you while I can that you have helped me immeasurably over the years. Your site is actually the most old-man user-friendly that I’ve looked at. Thank you so much for your research and insights; I refer you always to the young people I help start each year. These are difficult days but have a great year anyway on every level.
Thank you! I love to hear from people who have benefited from my site. It makes all the work seem worthwhile.
I have a hive that lost its queen at least a month ago (it’s the end of April in Connecticut). I purchased and introduced a new queen, and released her from her cage 8 days ago. She’s running around in the hive, but no sign of eggs, larvae or brood. My first thought was “new queen is unmated or infertile, need to get another one” but now I’m thinking what if the worker bees (there are still plenty of them) are not preparing cells for eggs to be laid. If they have all been foragers for quite a while now (months?) so maybe they’ve forgotten how to nurse, or just want to continue to be foragers. Any thoughts?
Honey bees do what needs to be done. So if foragers need to revert to nursing to save the colony, they can and will. I was wondering if you had a problem with laying workers, but if you see no eggs anywhere, then that doesn’t seem to be the case. Also, the fact the workers haven’t killed the new queen is another reason I don’t suspect laying workers.
However, I agree that after eight days of running around, she should be laying. It is possible something is wrong with her. Is this your only colony? If it is, and you don’t have any brood to give these bees, some workers will eventually begin to lay and that would be bad news.
I think you may need to get another queen but you need her right away. Do you belong to a club where you might be able to get one quickly? I don’t know what else to tell you. It’s possible this queen suddenly begins to lay in a day or two, but I think that’s a long shot.
Does anyone else have any thoughts on this?
I’m wondering what Andrew has observed about the worker behavior toward the new queen that he introduced. If she is “running around” and the workers are ignoring her, that sounds like a virgin to me. What does her abdomen look like? Is it enlarged like her ovaries are working? Or is it about the same length as a worker – which would also indicate an unmated queen?
She looks like most other queens that I’ve seen, definitely longer and fatter than a regular worker. Having said that, I don’t think I’ve ever seen an unmated queen to compare to.
Rusty, your analysis and insights are so valuable. Thank you.
Personally (and unscientifically), I think the reason there are no laying workers yet is that all the girls are too old!
I’m hunting down a new queen as fast as I can.
I can post a picture of the queen if there’s a way to do that, and maybe one of you can determine whether she’s mated or not.
She looks like a fully formed and mated queen to me. Cal? What do you think?
Sure does. Big fat abdomen.